Retired Physical Therapist: "They Cut A Nerve In Your Leg And Nobody Told You"

31 years rehabbing post-surgical knees exposes the 1 in 5 nobody warns you about — and why your knee still burns at 3am when the X-ray says you're fine

I'm about to piss off every orthopedic surgeon, pain clinic, and physical therapy practice in America.

Including the one I ran for 19 years.

Because if you understand what I'm about to tell you, a lot of you will stop paying us.

But I don't care.

After watching my own wife cry on a bathroom floor at 4am...

After 31 years of clinical training that turned out to be useless to her...

After 8 months of being told she was "doing really well"...

I found something that changed everything.

And if you're reading this with your leg propped on a cushion, a gel pack going warm in the freezer, and a scar you can't bear the weight of a comforter on...

The next 5 minutes could be the most important of your year.

My name is Michael Renshaw.

I rehabbed post-surgical knees for 31 years. Hundreds of them.

I know the protocols. I know the timelines. I wrote half the exercise sheets myself.

And I'm about to expose the thing that keeps 1 in 5 knee replacement patients trapped in pain, while everyone involved records the operation as a success.

But first, let me tell you the first thing nobody told us.

They Cut A Nerve In Your Leg

Not by accident.

On purpose. In the first minutes of your operation. As a matter of total routine.

The standard incision for a knee replacement goes straight through the infrapatellar branch of the saphenous nerve.

Some studies put that at over half of every knee replacement performed.

That numb patch beside your scar.

The one you assumed was swelling that never went down. The one you touch in the shower wondering if the feeling is ever coming back.

That's the nerve. It's cut. It has been since the day of your surgery.

Did anybody tell you?

Or are you finding out right now, from a stranger, months later, the same way I did?

The Night I Realized I Was Useless

Here's the thing though.

I'm not writing this for my wife. She sleeps now.

I'm writing it because I know exactly what you're doing at the moment you're reading this.

By day, you're doing well. That's not sarcasm. It's true.

You're off the cane. You hit every PT number. Your daughter says you're walking so much better. Your neighbor says you'd never know.

Every one of them is telling the truth.

Then everyone goes home, it gets dark, and you meet the other knee.

You lie as still as you physically can, because the second you move, it starts.

Leg straight. Leg bent. Pillow underneath. Pillow between your knees. Leg hanging off the side of the bed like a fool.

None of it matters.

The moment you go still it starts throbbing deep in the joint, in time with your own heartbeat, and you lie there counting until the sky goes gray.

You've propped the covers up off your knee with a cushion, because the weight of a comforter on that scar is unbearable.

So now you're freezing, with your leg in a tent, at 3 in the morning, months after the operation that was supposed to fix this.

And at some point you get up and walk through a dark house to the freezer, to swap a gel pack that's gone warm for one that hasn't.

Most nights. Some nights twice.

I know that walk.

I used to lie in the dark and listen to my wife make it, down our stairs, every single night, with 31 years of clinical training and nothing to offer her.

One night in February I found her sitting on the bathroom floor at 4am.

Not crying loudly. Just sitting with her back against the tub, tears running down her face.

"I don't think I can keep doing this."

And then she apologized to me for waking me up.

She apologized. To me.

So I know what it costs you to not mention it.

Because nobody sees the 3am version of you. Not your surgeon. Not your PT. Not your family.

And when you finally do say something, carefully, because you don't want to seem ungrateful after everything they did...

What comes back is that you're doing really well.

A woman on a recovery forum put it better than I ever managed. She wrote that she had a lot of pain at night that nothing seemed to touch, and that she was beginning to think she was losing her mind, especially since she was being told she was doing so well.

Nothing seemed to TOUCH it.

Remember that word. It turns out to be the most accurate word in this whole article.

I Know Your List. We Worked Through The Identical One.

Ice, exactly on protocol. 3 to 4 sessions a day, 20 minutes each, leg elevated.

That's over an hour a day sitting still with a frozen bag strapped on. Plus getting up in the night on top of it.

That's the plan. That is the state of the art aftercare for a $40,000 operation.

A bag of frozen gel and a note telling you to get up every 2 hours.

Then everything else:

• Physical therapy? Twice a week for 11 weeks. You never missed one. You have the folder.
• Cooling gel from the drugstore? Goes cold for 20 minutes, then nothing.
• Heat patches? Slide off in the night and turn up stuck to the bedsheet.
• A numbing roll-on? Quit before you were even asleep.
• Diclofenac gel? Did a little on the surface. Never once reached the part that actually hurt.
• Something prescription? You came off it because of what it did to your head or your stomach. Or you're still on it and quietly don't love being on it.

And then you went back to the surgeon.

You waited 6 weeks for that appointment.

He put your scan on the screen, pointed at the implant, and said textbook. Sitting beautifully.

He said it with his hand already on the door handle.

Eleven minutes.

You waited 6 weeks for 11 minutes and a man telling you to give it time with his coat half on.

Give it time is not a diagnosis.

It's what we say when we've run out of things to offer you and we want you to leave the room.

I know, because I've said it. I've stood in a treatment room and said give it time to somebody's wife, and I never once thought about what she went home to.

Now go look at your follow-up card.

Six weeks. Then twelve months.

Look at that gap.

Now think about where your pain actually sits on that calendar. Month 4. Month 7. Month 11.

The entire stretch where this thing owns your nights is the exact stretch where nobody in that building has an appointment booked with you.

That's not bad luck. That's THE SCHEDULE.

The system is paid to install the implant and to check the implant.

Nobody is paid to find out whether you sleep. So nobody asks.

And if you push? Another appointment. Another injection. Another scan. A referral to a pain clinic. Possibly, eventually, a revision.

Every one of those is billable.

Your ongoing pain isn't a failure of that system.

It's a revenue stream. I spent 19 years running a practice that was part of it.

The Real Reason Your Knee Still Hurts

This is the part that took me 8 months.

And I'm still angry I had to go find it myself, because it isn't hidden. It's published. It's free.

Any one of us could have read it to you.

Here's what they don't sit you down and explain:

You are 1 in 5. And they knew that before they wheeled you in.

Chronic pain after a knee replacement, meaning pain still there 3 months and beyond, runs at around 21% of patients.

One in five.

They told you about infection. They told you about clots. They had you initial both.

Nobody said that roughly 1 in 5 people are still in pain months later, and we won't know if you're one of them until you already are.

They don't have that conversation, because that conversation costs them consent.

Now the second fact, and this one should be on the wall of every orthopedic waiting room in America.

When they looked inside the knees of patients with persistent pain after a replacement, 80% had moderate to severe synovitis.

In the patients with no pain? 19%.

Synovitis is inflammation of the joint lining. It's soft tissue. It is NOT the implant.

And it does not appear on the X-ray your surgeon was pointing at.

Then the third fact.

That nerve they cut can go wrong. Usually it just leaves a numb patch and nothing worse.

Sometimes it forms a neuroma at the cut end, and that causes ongoing pain at the front of the knee in up to about 10% of first operations and 21% of revisions.

In the literature it's described as an "undervalued" cause of persistent pain after this surgery.

Undervalued. That's the medical word for nobody is looking for it.

So when he told you the scan was textbook, he wasn't lying.

He was telling the truth about the only thing that scan can see.

An X-ray images metal and bone. It cannot image an inflamed joint lining. It cannot image a cut nerve.

Here's all of it in one sentence. Read it twice.

Your operation succeeded. The metal is perfect. And the pain you have left is sitting in the lining, the capsule, and a cut nerve. All soft tissue. None of which appear on the scan they used to tell you that you're fine.

You're not imagining it. You're not weak. You're not failing your recovery.

You were assessed with a tool that is physically incapable of seeing the thing that hurts.

And I let that happen to my own wife, because I was trained inside the same system and I never questioned it either.

Why Every Cream You Bought Was Never Going To Work

Now the second half. This is where I have to admit I was part of the problem.

For 31 years, when patients asked me about pain creams, I told them the same thing.

"It's bone on bone. No cream is going to touch that."

And I was right. No cream on earth fixes bone on bone. It can't.

I said it with complete confidence, hundreds of times, and I was correct every single time.

I'd guess you've said it too. Probably standing in an aisle holding a tube you weren't going to buy.

But look at what both of us did.

You formed that belief BEFORE your surgery, when it was completely true.

Then you carried it straight through the operation without ever going back to check whether it was still true afterward.

You are not bone on bone anymore.

There is metal in there. Your own surgeon put the picture on a screen to prove it to you.

What's left is the lining, the capsule, and a sensory nerve somebody cut on the way in.

Every one of those is soft tissue. Sitting directly underneath your skin.

Which makes it the one and only thing a cream could ever have reached.

The X-ray he showed you to prove you were fine is the same X-ray that proves what you have left is reachable.

So then the question is why the creams did nothing.

And the answer made me want to put something through a wall.

Go get one of those tubes out of your bathroom cabinet. Turn it over. Read the back, not the front.

Menthol. Camphor. Maybe methyl salicylate.

Now get another one. The same. And another. The same.

Forty boxes on that shelf. Forty prices. About 3 ingredients between all of them.

You did not fail at choosing. There was nothing there to choose.

And menthol isn't treating anything.

Menthol is a counter irritant. It fires the cold receptors in your skin so your brain has something else to pay attention to for 20 minutes.

That's the whole job. It's not medicine, it's a distraction.

And your nerves adapt to it in about a third of an hour, which is exactly what you've been noticing for months.

Then there's the part that genuinely embarrasses me as a clinician.

Skin is a barrier. Keeping things out is its literal function.

And the molecules in an ordinary pain cream are far too big to pass through it.

Roughly 1 to 2.5% of what's in that tube ever gets past the surface.

The other 98% sits on your leg and evaporates.

You have been rubbing 98% of everything you ever bought onto the OUTSIDE of your own knee.

And people like me have been handing you the tube.

It's like trying to push a tennis ball through a keyhole.

It doesn't matter how good the tennis ball is.

It's Not A Better Tennis Ball. It's A Smaller One.

Which brings me to the only thing that has worked. And the reason it works is almost insultingly simple.

It's called NanoXtreme, and the entire principle is particle size.

The actives are made small enough to actually pass the skin barrier instead of sitting on top of it.

Absorption is around 10%, against the 1 to 2.5% you get from a standard drugstore cream.

That's not a marketing adjective. It's a clearance problem, and somebody finally solved the clearance problem.

There are 19 active botanicals in it, rather than one active and a lot of filler.

And it warms rather than freezes.

That will throw you at first, because you've spent months treating the cold hit as evidence that something was happening.

The cold hit was never the evidence. The cold hit was the distraction.

Check Availability Now →

My Wife's Honest Timeline

I've spent 31 years watching people get promised miracles. I'm not doing that to you.

Night 1. She rubbed it in before bed. It went in properly. No film on the surface, no grease. A warmth, and underneath the warmth something neither of us recognized from the others.

That's all that happened. She did not sleep through.

I want to be very clear that she did not sleep through, because if I tell you she did, you won't believe the rest of this. And you'd be right not to.

End of week 1. She slept until 5. That hadn't happened since before the operation. She woke me up to tell me, and we lay there working out how long it had been.

Week 2. She stopped making the noise getting out of the recliner. She didn't know she'd been making a noise. I'd known for months and never said anything.

Week 3. She didn't go down to the freezer once. Not one night in 7. Neither of us decided that. We just noticed at the end of the week that it hadn't happened.

Week 5. A whole afternoon in the yard, and she mentioned the knee once, right at the end, standing up. That hadn't happened in over a year.

Week 8. The cushion came off the bed. The comforter lies flat on her leg now and she doesn't think about it.

That's not a miracle and I won't dress it up as one.

It's still a knee that's had a joint replaced. On cold mornings she still knows about it. After a long day she still knows about it.

But she sleeps.

And I haven't lain in the dark listening to her go down the stairs since March.

The 5 Things People Asked Me

I put all of this on a recovery forum and got the same 5 objections back.

So let me answer them with other people's words instead of mine.

"I've tried every cream on that shelf."

"I was skeptical because I have used so many pain and muscle creams and they only work topically. The skin feels cool or warm but the pain is still very noticeable underneath. This actually truly makes the burning feel better."Amanda K.

"Post-surgical is different. Mine is nerve pain."

"I have tried a lot of different things for nerve pain after my total knee replacement. I wish I would have had it right after my surgery May 4th. I am having my other knee done July 31st. I will be using NanoXtreme after this surgery for sure."Cindy S.

"How is a cream doing what surgery couldn't?"

"I have waited a month to write this review to make sure I was giving good feedback. I am an old Physical Therapist, and very pleased the NanoX took the joint pain I have been dealing with from a level 7 to a 1. It did take 2 weeks of consistent use."Janet O.

"How long before I know?"

"I was skeptical about this product but after 6 days I found that this product really works. I have painful arthritis in both knees and have tried several different topical creams that are all mediocre at best. It works so well I can start walking again without any aids."Karen M.

"I'm on a fixed income and I've wasted enough money."

"I have tried many other pain creams and this works the best of any of them. I wish it was not so expensive but it is worth every penny."Candace C.

"If this is real, why didn't my own surgeon mention it?"

Because it isn't his job. I mean that literally, not bitterly.

His job was to install a joint and confirm it seated correctly. It did.

He's measured on implant position and range of motion. Yours passed both.

Nobody in that building is measured on whether you sleep. So nobody in that building asks.

Your operation is recorded as a success. On every metric anybody bothers to write down, it is one.

You can be a complete clinical triumph and a wreck at 3am at the same time.

And there is no box anywhere on that form where those two facts ever meet.

"And why isn't it $300 then?"

Because it's a cream.

It's 19 botanicals ground small enough to get through skin. No device. No clinic. No appointment. Nobody has to be paid to be in a room with you.

The expensive part of your knee was never the ingredients.

What You've Already Paid

Let me show you what the alternatives cost, because you've probably paid most of them already.

The replacement itself: $30,000 to $50,000.

Cortisone injections: $100 to $300 each. And you never get one, you get a course.

Physical therapy: $75 to $150 a session. And you did 20 or more of them.

Prescription painkillers: monthly, indefinitely. Plus what they cost your stomach and your head.

And the ice, which is free, and which costs you 60 to 80 minutes a day plus a broken night. Every night. For months.

Add up what you've already spent managing a knee that is, officially, fixed.

We passed $2,000 and I stopped counting.

A tube of this is $49.99.

On subscription it's $39.99.

On the 5-pack subscription it works out to $27.99 a tube. 44% off.

I'll say this without any of that.

I wish somebody had put this in front of us at month 2 instead of month 8.

She doesn't get those 6 months back. Neither do you. And you're in the middle of yours right now.

Check Availability Now →

The 60-Day Guarantee. Even On An Empty Tube.

Look, I get it.

You've been burned before. Forty boxes on that shelf, remember.

So here's the promise.

60 days. Money back. And it applies even on an empty tube.

Use the whole thing. If it does nothing at all, say so, and you get your money back.

Why am I comfortable telling you that?

Because their real refund rate is 1.2% of sales.

I checked. After everything I've just described to you, I check things now.

The Two Versions Of Your Next 3 Months

Right now you're at a crossroads.

Path 1: Nothing changes.

The cushion stays propping the comforter off your leg. The gel packs stay in the freezer door.

You keep making that walk at 3am through a dark house.

And you keep being told you're doing really well by people who have never once seen you at 3am.

In March you're exactly where you are tonight. Except a year further into a life you've quietly started making smaller without deciding to.

Path 2: You try it.

You spend $40 on a tube of cream.

And the worst thing that can possibly happen is you mail an empty one back and lose nothing at all.

That's the entire decision.

It took me 8 months and a degree I already had.

It should take you one evening.

Check Availability Now →

Michael Renshaw
Physical Therapist, retired after 31 years
Still married to the woman who sleeps now

Comments